Tuesday, 15 May 2007

ED 4134 Item 2 Graphic Organiser

















Before analysing the learning advantages of the ICT (graphic organiser) I'd like to point out the following because I've only just figured this out and am now in a great debate as to the benefits / disadvantages of blogs versus wiki's!! Unlike wikis, blogs do not allow a user / viewer to access external programs so in effect what you see is what you get. Within the scope of a blog, graphic organisers such as Inspiration 8 are limited. However stagnant graphic organisers are beneficial to the visual, naturalist and logical learner as they can be manipulated to stress hierarchical patterns, commonalities and differences of information. A good range of examples and comparisons of graphic organisers can be found at http://www.graphic.org/goindex.html

Use of the Inspiration 8 program outside of a blog is appealing (in addition to the above) to the existential and kinesthetic learner. According to Petty, the interaction element - physically having to explore the page, open hyperlinks and expand the ideas by reading the 'post its' behind the main label all help the student internalise the information being presented.

Inspiration 8 allows the student to follow ideas / concepts at their own pace and in a way that makes the most sense to them. Vygotsky understood that people are greatly influenced by their environment therefore the learning of the digital native is reinforced through use of ICT. Hattie is quoted as saying "it is what students bring to the table that predicts achievement more than any other variable". It therefore makes sense to use ICT when teaching because it is a medium that the students are apt in and engage positively with. Potentially use of ICT could raise the level of achievement. Interpersonal and intrapersonal learning is therefore accommodated by use of this ICT.

The way this ICT is used effects is ability to be an effective learning tool. Where teachers readily display information on graphic organisers which are THEN used by students Bloom's Taxonomy is being implemented only to the point of knowledge, possibly comparison. When the student uses the graphic organiser to collate and link information in a way that personally make sense to them the application / analysis stage is being implemented.

References:
Gardner Multiple Intelligences http://surfaquarium.com/MI/index.htm
Hattie, J. (2005). What is the Nature of Evidence That Makes a Difference to Learning? www.acer.edu.au/workshops/documents/HattieSlides.pdf
Petty, G. (2004) What the Learner does is more important than what the teacher does. www.geoffpetty.com/research.html
Vygotsky Social Development Thoery http://tip.psychology.org/vygotsky.html
Inspiration 8

Tuesday, 8 May 2007

Multiple Intelligences in the ICT Environment


How do we manage multiple intelligences in the ICT environment?

AIM: To answer this question as a collaborative group using the links below...

Explore e-learning This is a catalogue of resources for Teaching Maths and Science in Secondary schools http://www.explorelearning.com/index.cfm?method=cResource.dspResourceCatalog
This is a site that provides a wide range of activities based on Gardner's multiple intelligences (fantastic site!) http://surfaquarium.com/mi/intelligences.htm

This site provides a number of very useful sites in relation to Gardener's MI with ideas for the classroom and the use of ICThttp://hometown.aol.com/abctagteam/multiple_intelligences.htm

Applying Bloom's Taxonomy in the classroomThis gives you concrete leads....but how do you use it in the ICT environment?http://www.teachers.ash.org.au/researchskills/dalton.htm

There are a number of different sites that link you into research on e-learning and current trends. This site won't provide you with an immediate answer but it will help you begin collaborating with those who are researching in this field.http://www.ncsl.org.uk/networked/index.cfm

Constructivist learning theory...don't forget that you are basing all this work on this theory. This is a good summary for you and not too technical.http://www.exploratorium.edu/ifi/resources/constructivistlearning.html

This site from Bradford England goes through the various intelligences and gives you possible activities in ICT to use to develop particular intelligences. While it is way beyond our technologies it is good to know because schools are getting these resources. There are also an increasing number of these technologies available as free software.http://www.bradfordschools.net/content/view/226/182

Tools and resources provided by Intel for free to support collaborative student centered learning. Online thinking tools are active learning places where students engage in robust discussions, pursue investigations, analyse complex information and solve problems. Resources for 21st century teaching help teachers play a critical role in facilitating learning activities and posing questions that take student thinking deeper.http://www.intel.com/education/tools/index.htm


Thursday, 5 April 2007

ED 4134 Item 1 Hattie

Descriptive Reflection

Professor John Hattie set out to define the attributes that form a quality teacher. He believes that once these attributes are justified (by his own and others research) they can be used to develop and defend high quality teacher education programs. Hattie highlights the fact that in the past unsatisfactory teacher performance and consequently student performance, has often been dealt with by means of a reorganisation of systems already in play, he gives the example of decreasing class sizes. Hattie distinguishes between expert and experienced teachers by describing how expert teachers stimulate deep learning, as opposed to surface learning, in their students. Expert teachers differ from experienced teachers in three main areas – the way they represent their classrooms, the degree of challenges they present to students and the depth of processing that their students attain (Hattie, 2003).

Critical Reflection

Hattie is a breath of fresh air among the many psychological theories being battered around. After proposing the development of teacher training programs with the view to a renewal of focus on the success of our teachers to make a difference it is refreshing to note his effort in obtaining a broad range of data to defend the program. Hattie’s research seems to take from many of the psychological models and combine them into a practical, scientifically supported approach to learning. Hattie is not a psychologist and this is evident from his lack of wanting to push either an obvious cognitive or social framework of learning. However, although the article focus is on teachers and Hattie justifies the teacher as being the next major influence on student learning, I would like to know more about his opinions on peer learning and whether he places any value on it.

References

Hattie, J (2003). Teachers Make a Difference: What is the research evidence?
Retrieved on March 28; 2007, from
http://tonymcarthur.edublogs.org/files/2007/02/hattie_teachers_make_a_difference.pdf

ED 4234 Item 1 Glasser

Descriptive Reflection

Behavioural psychotherapist William Glasser developed a model of behavioural therapy he renamed Choice Theory in 1998. Choice Theory was originally designed for use by anyone who worked in a social profession. More recently Glasser’s theory has been revamped for specific use in school environments. Choice Theory works on the basis that almost all behaviour is chosen. Glasser argues that when an individual consciously takes responsibility for their chosen behaviour they begin to actively engage with a more positive approach to daily life (Wikipedia, 2007). In his book Control Theroy Glasser argues that we spend too much time on discipline in schools when rather we should be concentrating on effective learning strategies. He suggests that effective education is about “using and improving knowledge” and advocates a policy of open learning in schools. Glasser lists seven caring habits that when utilised by teachers will help produce strong peer and student/teacher relationships and create a constructive learning environment.

Critical Reflection

In theory Glasser’s model of behavioural therapy seems reasonable and even achievable. However, there are issues about the overall effectiveness regarding the actual implementation of his theory. Unless all children are to be schooled in a Glasser quailty school from a very early age the idea of “open learning” risks gaps in their education. Open learning possesses potential time management problems and could lead to an increase in learning diversity ranges within a class. In Critera for a Quality School Glasser proposes that trust and respect eliminate discipline problems, but not incidents. Kids will be kids. Although the concept of encouraging positive attitudes is a good idea it is not realistic to expect all school age children to actively engage with this theory. Glasser also fails to acknowledge external influences and pressures such as individual temperament, hormonal changes in adolescents, economic stresses at home etc.
References

ED 4134 Item 1 Bruner

Descriptive Reflection

Jerome Bruner’s Constructivist Learning Theory is based on the concept of categorization. Bruner states that a person of any age, even very young children, are capable of understanding any concept provided the instruction is within the realm of their ability to comprehend and perform. This is similar to the concept of domain specific learning. Bruner’s idea of building up specific knowledge is based on Bloom’s Taxonomy .

Bruner requires the following principles for learning; a readiness to learn, an appropriate teaching method that suits the student and an effective sequence in which to present the material if this is successful the end result should be that the student reaches a point where they can go beyond the given information and draw their own conclusions based on their individual knowledge and problem solving ability (Wikipedia, 2007).

Critical Reflection

Like Piaget, Bruner’s ideas are classified as cognitive constructionist theory however Bruner seems to be a bit more in tune with the concept of domain specific learning, as opposed to Piaget who generalised broad stages of development. Bruner’s stages of development in children are based on three representations but these stages are not as rigid as Piaget’s and “translate” into one another. As teacher’s we can take from Bruner the concept that just because a student possesses an advanced understanding in one subject area this does mean this immediately apply to other areas of learning. As facilitators of learning we need to be aware of how best to guide students in making discoveries for themselves.
References

ED 4134 Item 1 Piaget

Descriptive Reflection

Jean Piaget’s Cognitive Development Theory is concerned with the measurement of children’s cognitive development which he organized into the following four stages;

Sensorimotor Stage (birth to 2yrs)
Preoperational Stage (2yrs-6/7yrs)
Concrete Stage (6/7yrs-11/12yrs)
Formal Operations Stage (11/12-adult)

Piaget comes from a cognitive constructivist school of thought because he believed a child advanced to the next stage once a state of equilibrium had been reached through the self construction of knowledge. He saw children as “independent explorers” who were “active in the problem solving process” (Silverthorn, 1999).

Piaget taught us that children’s reasoning and thought processes differ to adults. After testing Piaget’s Cognitive Development Theory across hundreds of cultures it seems he was reasonably accurate in describing the content and sequence of learning. Piaget’s concept of stages has been applied to many other aspects of human development (Sigelman et al, 1995).

Critical Reflection

Piaget made a sweeping claim that broad stages of development exist whereas more recent research suggests that cognitive development is more likely to be domain specific and continuous. Unlike Vygotsky's social constructivist view, Piaget's stage theory suggests an endpoint in development(Sigelman et al, 1995).

Piaget failed to distinguish competence from performance. As Sigelman et al point out “when a subject failed a task Piaget assumed it was because they were unable to grasp the concept he was testing” He did not account for other influencing factors of performance such as motivation, verbal abilities, memory etc. (Sigelman et al, 1995). Piaget often neglected social influences because he was more concerned with identifying cognitive structures that influenced performance.

By critiquing the work of Piaget and Vygotsky we begin to recognise the importance of both cognitive and social develpoment theories and the impact this research has on being able to cater for different learning styles. As teacher’s we can manipulate and mix learning theories to extract the best results from individual students.

References
Sigelman, C. K. & Shaffer, D. R (1995). Life Span Human Development. 2nd Ed. Brooks Cole Publishing. Pacific Grove, California.

Wednesday, 4 April 2007

ED 4134 Item 1 Vygotsky

Descriptive Reflection:

Lev Vygotsky’s Social Development Theory is a social constructivist model emphasising the impact of social influences on cognitive development ‘Cognitive growth occurs in a social context and evolves out of the child’s social interactions’ (Siegelman et al, 1995).

He believed learning occurred in what he dubbed the Zone of Proximal Development. This is the area of difference between what a child can accomplish alone and what they can accomplish with the guidance of more mature thinkers (Wikipedia, 2007). Vygotsky argued that children learn more sophisticated cognitive strategies through interaction with more competent individuals. By internalizing advanced problem solving methods the student is building a scaffold.

Vygotsky also had clear views about the importance of how language shaped thought. He described how social speech becomes private speech and later inner speech. Although Vygotsky’s research primarily concentrated on the cognitive development of children, he saw learning as a life long process (Riddle, 1999) .


Critical Reflection:

Interest in Vygotsky’s Social Development Theory is being revived on account of dissatisfaction with the conditioning approach to learning. Prensky’s Digital Natives, Digital Immigrants essay argues that today’s students are ‘hardwired’ differently meaning traditional student / teacher interactions are becoming a less effective method of learning.

Vygotsky’s emphasise on guided learning can be appropriated in a contemporary learning environment where teacher’s are being encouraged to take a more passive role. The concept that children internalise methods of problem solving shown to them by more mature thinkers (be they other students or teachers) who are sensitive to their zone of proximal development becomes apparent through the observation of group work (Sigelman et al, 1995). Although the benefits of this type of interaction are notable and not to be underestimated, in a real classroom situation the time restraints may mean that more direct methods of teaching are sometimes more constructive.
References

Riddle, E. M. (1999). Lev Vygotsky’s Social Development Theory. Retrieved in March 28, 2007, from
http://tonymcarthur.edublogs.org/files/2007/03/vygotsky1.htm

Sigelman, C. K. & Shaffer, D. R (1995). Life Span Human Development. 2nd Ed. Brooks Cole Publishing. Pacific Grove, California.

http://www.marxists.org/archive/vygotsky/works/1933/play.htm

http://www.marxists.org/archive/vygotsky/works/words/index.htm

http://www.marcprensky.com/writing/Prensky%20-%20Digital%20Natives,%20Digital%20Immigrants%20-%20Part1.pdf

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lev_Vygpotsky